Skip to content
Slotmark1085

‘Criminal Women’: The Societal Tag for Incarcerated Women. However, Consider If This Tag is Untrue?

“Detaining a woman inevitably means detaining her family,” a young mother in Sierra Leone explained to me, holding her infant child in a damp cell. This sentiment recalls a individual experience from my youth, hearing my mother cry after learning my father had been arrested for political motives in Zambia.

I am acutely aware how children become the unintended victims of imprisonment. During my career as a lawyer, I have seen that this is especially the case when women, who are frequently the main caretakers – are the ones taken away.

I have observed the destructive consequences of imprisonment on hundreds of women and their children. Furthermore, I have seen how their perspectives are dismissed, even within discussions on female empowerment.

Unraveling the ‘Bad Girl’ Label

The public often brands women in prison as “bad girls.” But what if this label is a falsehood? The greater part of incarcerated women are imprisoned for non-violent offences. Extensive research conducted over the last 24 months indicates that in a high percentage of situations, women are penalized due to poverty, mental health challenges, abuse or prejudice.

Half of all women in custody, compared to a smaller fraction of men, report a substance dependency in the time leading up to their arrest.

In a South African correctional facility, a woman shared her arrest for stealing, an act of desperation to feed her family. In Sierra Leone, countless women were documented to be arrested for financial obligations. In Kenya, stories abound of women arrested for “informal selling” – trading items without a licence – simply to survive.

Women from Mexico detailed how the international drug enforcement policies is contributing to an increase in the number of women behind bars, particularly in Latin America and Asia. Many women sell drugs due to poverty and pressure; though not major players in the narcotics network, they are simpler targets for arrest by police under pressure to show results.

Violence as a Consequence, Not a Cause

The small proportion of women who commit violent crimes are often individuals with a history of trauma themselves. For instance, 21-year-old Chisomo from Malawi, arrested for the murder of her former partner. He had attacked her and threatened to kill her if she left. Chisomo ultimately ran away after he made an attempt on her life. Yet, he eventually confronted her again, cutting her. In a moment of survival, she took hold of the blade and struck back.

My efforts have involved lawyers across the globe who fight for legal processes to consider a woman’s background of poverty and abuse. Yet, even with this work, a judicial framework created with a male perspective continues to let women down through inherent biases. Those who deviate from traditional stereotypes of the idealized feminine role are often given more severe penalties.

Prisons are not safe spaces for women. Vulnerable women go into prison and are released with deeper psychological wounds.

My research has recorded instances where women have been subjected to assault and where procedures like humiliating bodily searches and solitary confinement inflict additional trauma to women with pasts involving assault or mental health challenges. Imprisoned women’s rates of suicidal behavior are often exceed those in prisons for men.

In spite of international standards stipulating that prison should be a ultimate measure, especially for pregnant women and women with small kids, tragic stories persist of women who miscarry and of newborns who do not survive in prison.

The Invisible Victims: Children

Children – whether with their mothers in detention or separated at home – are the unseen sufferers. Estimates suggest there are at least 19,000 children detained in prison with their mothers, while a astonishing 1.4 million children have a mother in prison.

The cycle of trauma of parental imprisonment on children are well researched. I vividly recall trying to locate the offspring of a hopeless woman in Sierra Leone, who had no knowledge what had happened to them after her arrest. A neighbour had cared for them but the child went to vend goods the street to support herself and was lost forever.

A Systemic Oversight

One of the primary disappointments is how the imprisonment of women remains a blind spot. Major conferences on female empowerment, where agendas and budgets are set, repeatedly omit this vital topic. Notably, there was not a single reference of imprisoned females in the political declaration at the UN Commission on the Status of Women this year.

Studies show that organisations working with and for incarcerated women are critically underfunded, even by funders of rights-based and gender equality initiatives. For many years, negative labeling, a desire to promote only “palatable victims” and the marginalization of those who fail to conform neat narratives has meant that disadvantaged females and their children are neglected, in the face of promises to “include everyone.”

Glimmers of Hope and Reform

However, alongside witnessing suffering, there exists optimism. Internationally, women are rethinking what fairness might entail, from both inside and outside prison walls. In Colombia, campaigners helped pass an progressive legislation allowing women to undertake rehabilitative work rather than face imprisonment in particular situations.

In Sierra Leone, gender justice advocates successfully fought against outdated vagrancy statutes. In the UK, female-focused rehabilitation hubs offer a blueprint of community support that is more effective and less costly than prison.

Two years ago, at the first convening of a international coalition of women with prison experience, I cried hearing stories of women transforming deep suffering into something empowering, building collective strength and working together to change the structures that impact their lives.

As the number of women in prison keeps increasing at an alarming rate – reportedly faster than that of men – and we head towards the sobering milestone of over a million women in prison worldwide, this serves as a critical alert.

The Need for Responsibility and Movement

Next year offers key advocacy opportunities to address this neglect – from major UN meetings to influential feminist conferences.

Nations should be made responsible for their {failure to implement|inability

About the author

Maureen Villarreal

A seasoned gaming analyst with over a decade of experience in casino strategy and slot machine mechanics.

Slotmark1085

Type to search articles.